Introduction is compelling, succinct, and clear
• Engages the reader
• Provides detailed background
information
• Defines the central problem or
issue
• Identification of the central claim
being examined
• Outlines the key premises
• Description of argument strategy
Body
Well-developed and clearly stated central claim
• All elements of the argument are present
• Claims and sub-claims are elaborate, clear, and succinct
• Description of evidence
• Established warrant
• Clear elaboration and responses
to objections using a systematic
method
• Clear connections between
sentences
• Clear flow between paragraphs
• Clear build-up of argument
• Diagram of argument embedded
in document
• (change paragraphs when sub-
topic changes)
Conclusion
• Effectively ties together the argument made in the body of the essay
• Summarizes the main points without simply repeating the introduction
Writing is smooth and coherent throughout the entire essay
• Collegiate level vocabulary and writing style applied
• Minor (1-2) grammatical or punctuation errors
• Minor (1-2) spelling errors